YouTube

better support cast

Ben was a better QB than Eli but Eli had a better career. Taking down the 18-0 Patriots is too legendary.

Boogersugar said Ben was a better QB than Eli but Eli had a better career. Taking down the 18-0 Patriots is too legendary.

Yup.

Beat them twice too, definitely got a better career than Ben.

Makes the case? That's the easiest case to make in history. Eli is so overrated it's hilarious. He was carried to two chips by his defense and he played for the Giants. Other than that the dude didn't even make the playoffs half the seasons he was in the league. Do you know that's impossible for a HOF QB to do?


Fun fact: Eli Manning 15+ seasons as Giants QB, 6 playoff appearances
Joe Flacco 10 seasons as Ravens QB, 6 playoff appearances

I'll say Ben had the better career. I believe him teams were better.

Not discrediting Eli or anything and those two SBs.

Eli was a turnover machine.

Tikyle2 said Makes the case? That's the easiest case to make in history. Eli is so overrated it's hilarious. He was carried to two chips by his defense and he played for the Giants. Other than that the dude didn't even make the playoffs half the seasons he was in the league. Do you know that's impossible for a HOF QB to do?

Career for career...Ben had better teams around him than Eli pretty consistently but couldn't match the success when it counted most

SASknows nothing about football

There’s no need to even acknowledge this take

If Ben and it's not even close. Both have two super bowl wins and similar TD and yards per season. Ben has a way better win-loss record. Neither had an incredible individual season but what really separates them is the turnovers.

White privilege has been good to both of them. Eli was trash in his prime. Ben was trash only in the very beginning when he was an active rapist. Ben had a better career, is a better player, and one day will have a documentary on lifetime.

Ben has higher yards, completion %, touchdowns, yards per attempt, QB rating is higher by like 10 points, higher TD % and lower int % and lower total interceptions. Eli Manning's TD:Int ratio is no where near 2.

So basically Ben threw for more touchdowns and yards at a higher yards per attempt while throwing for less interceptions (both absolute and percentage wise)....

What is there to "make the case for"?



Eli Manning was a middling QB his entire career as evidenced by his .500 record. Two Superbowl runs and the family name is the only reason he's even talked about this sh*t is ridiculous.

Ben belongs in the hall of fame. Eli does not. There shouldn't be comparisons between the two.

Lil Jay 05 said I'll say Ben had the better career. I believe him teams were better. Not discrediting Eli or anything and those two SBs. Eli was a turnover machine.

So was Bret Favre. Eli took chances, second half of his career he had NO offensive line…kinda how we still don’t have one

TriniSoldier said White privilege has been good to both of them. Eli was trash in his prime. Ben was trash only in the very beginning when he was an active rapist. Ben had a better career, is a better player, and one day will have a documentary on lifetime.

#SurvivingBigRape

This is stupid.

2-1 Superbowl.

aaf192020 said If Ben and it's not even close. Both have two super bowl wins and similar TD and yards per season. Ben has a way better win-loss record. Neither had an incredible individual season but what really separates them is the turnovers.

Eli saved us from non-stop Brady chatter. Imagine if he won both of those games, especially the 17-0 year, it would be more insufferable than it already is.

Eli had a 117-117 record and threw for 57,023 yards with 366 touchdowns and 244 interceptions. ... By comparison, Roethlisberger has a 144-71-1 record through 16 seasons, passing for 56,545 yards with 363 touchdown passes and 191 interceptions. His career 94.0 passer rating is about 10 points higher than Manning's.






Are we really comparing these 2

If you look at how both played in the Superbowls its not even close. Everything else is background noise. Superbowls are where QBs distance themselves from each other.

Coffee said This is stupid. 2-1 Superbowl.

You realize they both won two Super Bowls, right?

Ben beat the Seahawks and the Cardinals.

Tikyle2 said Makes the case? That's the easiest case to make in history. Eli is so overrated it's hilarious. He was carried to two chips by his defense and he played for the Giants. Other than that the dude didn't even make the playoffs half the seasons he was in the league. Do you know that's impossible for a HOF QB to do? Fun fact: Eli Manning 15+ seasons as Giants QB, 6 playoff appearances Joe Flacco 10 seasons as Ravens QB, 6 playoff appearances

Disses Eli Manning and says he was carried by his defense then posts Joe Flacco

BEASTMODE863 said Eli saved us from non-stop Brady chatter. Imagine if he won both of those games, especially the 17-0 year, it would be more insufferable than it already is.

Fxck that. I'm still mad I lost all that bread on multiple bets. Nxgga didn't have nothing after paying off them debts. Drove to work hungry with no gas just fumes the whole week.

Pythagoras said Ben has higher yards, completion %, touchdowns, yards per attempt, QB rating is higher by like 10 points, higher TD % and lower int % and lower total interceptions. Eli Manning's TD:Int ratio is no where near 2. So basically Ben threw for more touchdowns and yards at a higher yards per attempt while throwing for less interceptions (both absolute and percentage wise).... What is there to "make the case for"? Eli Manning was a middling QB his entire career as evidenced by his .500 record. Two Superbowl runs and the family name is the only reason he's even talked about this sh*t is ridiculous. Ben belongs in the hall of fame. Eli does not. There shouldn't be comparisons between the two.

Eli's a Manning and has 2 SB rings. There no chance he wont' get in. But to compare him to Ben is goofy at best. People act like Ben didn't compete against Prime Peyton & Prime GOAT most of his career. Even got Peyton on the road in the playoffs during the 1st SB run. AND played in the division w/the Ravens when they were a SB contender regularly. Against Prime Ed Reed and Prime Ray Lewis. Ben earned everything in his career. Gotta respect it.

yumflip said Eli's a Manning and has 2 SB rings. There no chance he wont' get in. But to compare him to Ben is goofy at best. People act like Ben didn't compete against Prime Peyton & Prime GOAT most of his career. Even got Peyton on the road in the playoffs during the 1st SB run. AND played in the division w/the Ravens when they were a SB contender regularly. Against Prime Ed Reed and Prime Ray Lewis. Ben earned everything in his career. Gotta respect it.

Horrible. Embarrassment for the Hall seriously. But it is what it is. Privilege.

Pythagoras said Horrible. Embarrassment for the Hall seriously. But it is what it is. Privilege.

NFL's royal family. If this n*gga Arch make it and is good...

Stu Shiesty said Disses Eli Manning and says he was carried by his defense then posts Joe Flacco

I see it went over your head. Flacco is trash and no one is talking about him being in the Hall and he basically did better than Eli did in a shorter career.

This is a big duh..

Other then those patriot Super Bowls, the rest of Eli’s career was subpar af