3,880
 

Reed Or Polamalu?



ADVERTISEMENT
 
topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot 3X PLAT


most viewed right now
  79
49 replies  @wild'ish


section  x1   |  0 bx goons and 1 bystanders Share this on Twitter       Share this on Facebook

section sports
  
 2 months ago '06        #1
1309 page views
75 comments


droid3000  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x41
avatar
Props total: 80641 80 K  Slaps total: 10176 10 K
Reed Or Polamalu?
 

 

im sure most will say reed but i feel like its closer than we think
+9   



best
worst
75 comments
 

 2 months ago '11        #2
stashsoprano 
Props total: 8722 8 K  Slaps total: 973 973
reed
+26   

 2 months ago '07        #3
Bkjj11  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x77
Props total: 166191 166 K  Slaps total: 27748 27 K
Ed
+9   

 2 months ago '07        #4
TH35 
Props total: 38405 38 K  Slaps total: 4156 4 K
Reed.
+9   

 2 months ago '09        #5
The Bully  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x44
Props total: 161311 161 K  Slaps total: 33865 33 K
Edward
+7   

 2 months ago '12        #6
KUKOC 
Props total: 6362 6 K  Slaps total: 2471 2 K
Slight edge to Troy

When I try to compare two players at the same position I tried to switch their situation and think hypothetically

Steelers always had a decent defense but it's not comparable to what that Ravens defense was like

I can only imagine what it would be like for Troy to have Ray Ray, Ngata and Suggs etc

Reed was a better ball hawk and returner..Troy was a better tackler and run supporter

Very close tho..no wrong answer here

The craziest part is they almost played together on the Ravens
+10   

 2 months ago '16        #7
Replicate45 
Props total: 11603 11 K  Slaps total: 1590 1 K
sportsbook top 10
SB .520 #3 (+2)
Reed.
+4   

 2 months ago '14        #8
Kyu  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x28
Props total: 205256 205 K  Slaps total: 25037 25 K
Ima go with Reed but I rock with Troy as well
+7   

 2 months ago '15        #9
asap711 
Props total: 1856 1 K  Slaps total: 560 560
Ed reed
+5   

 2 months ago '21        #10
realsht92 
Props total: 1117 1 K  Slaps total: 170 170
Dumbass question.. Ed Reed….. #TheU
+6   

 2 months ago '16        #11
JayGeezus 
Props total: 3788 3 K  Slaps total: 408 408
E D Reed, boy. The best you ever seen, boy
+15   

 2 months ago '20        #12
adak31 
Props total: 14892 14 K  Slaps total: 456 456
Troy

 2 months ago '19        #13
Wiseone 
Props total: 1464 1 K  Slaps total: 248 248
Reed
+3   

 2 months ago '04        #14
NoLedge18720 
Props total: 15479 15 K  Slaps total: 2256 2 K
Reed. Troy is overrated because of a few hits and some diving interceptions. In reality dude was always getting caught looking in the backfield in coverage and it made him a liability more times than not. sh*t he's the reason Tebow beat the Steelers in the playoff game because he bit on the play action Reed is easily the better all-around safety and anyone who says Troy is a Steelers fan
+18   

 2 months ago '04        #15
booie4 
Props total: 5823 5 K  Slaps total: 423 423
I always thought that Reed was clearly better. Not by a ton, but better
+6   

 2 months ago '15        #16
Lockwind 
Props total: 1434 1 K  Slaps total: 1009 1 K
USC polamalu
+1   

Top 10 most propped recently  2 months ago '19        #17
aaf192020 
Props total: 42734 42 K  Slaps total: 4103 4 K
Ed Reed was that guy.
+1   

 2 months ago '11        #18
Killa KMS 
Props total: 2639 2 K  Slaps total: 123 123
Ed without even flinching about it.
+9   

 2 months ago '04        #19
TheDirector217 
Props total: 1931 1 K  Slaps total: 62 62
 NoLedge18720 said
Reed. Troy is overrated because of a few hits and some diving interceptions. In reality dude was always getting caught looking in the backfield in coverage and it made him a liability more times than not. sh*t he's the reason Tebow beat the Steelers in the playoff game because he bit on the play action Reed is easily the better all-around safety and anyone who says Troy is a Steelers fan
You ain't lie. No one in the history of the league said let's put Ed Reed in coverage so we can win. Aaron Rodgers got a chip off it vs. Polamalu. If you know football and watched the game, you know. These are simply inarguable facts, champ...
+5   

 1 month ago '18        #20
KdenIII 
Props total: 30882 30 K  Slaps total: 4571 4 K
 NoLedge18720 said
Reed. Troy is overrated because of a few hits and some diving interceptions. In reality dude was always getting caught looking in the backfield in coverage and it made him a liability more times than not. sh*t he's the reason Tebow beat the Steelers in the playoff game because he bit on the play action Reed is easily the better all-around safety and anyone who says Troy is a Steelers fan
yeah Polamalu took a lot of gambles but that's also what added to his legacy, jumping the line for sacks and TFLs so often. No risk, no reward.

I also think his athleticism was superior.. that one handed dive INT, some of the pick 6 run backs were halfback-esque.

BUT even as a Steelers fan I still gotta give the slight edge to Ed because he is probably the best ballhawk the league has ever seen. the stats show they both played each position to their strength anyway.


Last edited by KdenIII; 08-05-2021 at 07:38 AM..
+3   

 1 month ago '04        #21
NeXPhazE 
Props total: 1317 1 K  Slaps total: 163 163
 NoLedge18720 said
Reed. Troy is overrated because of a few hits and some diving interceptions. In reality dude was always getting caught looking in the backfield in coverage and it made him a liability more times than not. sh*t he's the reason Tebow beat the Steelers in the playoff game because he bit on the play action Reed is easily the better all-around safety and anyone who says Troy is a Steelers fan
The reason Tebow beat us in the playoffs is because Ryan Clark. He was out because he has sickle cell and we had a backup in. The backup got beat and troy was the closest so Troy gets the blame.... You're crazy to think Troy is overrated.
+2   

 1 month ago '18        #22
KdenIII 
Props total: 30882 30 K  Slaps total: 4571 4 K
 NeXPhazE said
The reason Tebow beat us in the playoffs is because Ryan Clark. He was out because he has sickle cell and we had a backup in. The backup got beat and troy was the closest so Troy gets the blame.... You're crazy to think Troy is overrated.
they just feel he was overrated cuz every time they turned on sportscenter they had to see his picks.

but really he doesn't get talked about as much as he should and is underrated.
+2   

 1 month ago '15        #23
rolnsupadoobies 
Props total: 546 546  Slaps total: 29 29
Reed
+1   

 1 month ago '04        #24
1000bluntz 
Props total: 34732 34 K  Slaps total: 8117 8 K
Steve Atwater was the baddest motherfu*ker ever at safety, dude makes even legends seem like pussies.
-2   

 1 month ago '17        #25
Pythagoras 
Props total: 42022 42 K  Slaps total: 8816 8 K
Reed. No doubt about it for me.
+2   



Sign me up
 
 

yesterday...


most viewed right now
+46online now  29
How The Air Jordan 1 High OG “Georgetown” Looks On-Feet
45 comments
1 day ago
@gear
most viewed right now
+47online now  27
Article inside Dying Careers to Avoid
159 comments
24 hours ago
@misc
most viewed right now
+16online now  16
Karen Civil getting called out by Nipsey's people on Clubhouse, she's in atten..
389 comments
1 day ago
@hiphop
most viewed right now
+214online now  11
cleveland is wild
133 comments
1 day ago
@wild'ish
back to top
register register Follow BX @ Twitter search BX privacyprivacy