4,403
 

Do yall agree? Yes 5 classics vs Hovs......... 3?


ADVERTISEMENT
 
2
most viewed right now
-39  108
65 comments @hiphop


section  x1   |  0 bx goons and 1 bystanders Share this on Twitter       Share this on Facebook

topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot 3X PLAT section hiphop
  
 1 month ago '11        #1
2226 page views
127 comments


Da Truth23  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x2
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9187 9 K  Slaps total: 1505 1 K
Do yall agree? Yes 5 classics vs Hovs......... 3?
 

 

I thought Hov had 5. Obviously yall know what 5 bro talking about but damn. Hov with 3 idk.

RD
TBP
TBA
VOL 2
AG?
-18   



best
worst
127 comments
 

 1 month ago '12        #2
PrimeLamboJr. 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9863 9 K  Slaps total: 1695 1 K
Both have 5... Ye just have 5 consecutively, which is unprecedented
+15   

 1 month ago '19        #3
somuchfun 
space
space
space
Props total: 1073 1 K  Slaps total: 392 392
Jay has 3 classics anyone that says more is d*ckeating

Kanye also has 3 IMO but he has ghostwriters
+21   

 1 month ago '11        #4
Da Truth23  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x2 OP
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9187 9 K  Slaps total: 1505 1 K
 PrimeLamboJr. said
Both have 5... Ye just have 5 consecutively, which is unprecedented
Yeah Ye is a legend for sure. Just the last 3 has been rough.

We might can say they have 6 with WTT?
+7   

 1 month ago '11        #5
Da Truth23  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x2 OP
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9187 9 K  Slaps total: 1505 1 K
 somuchfun said
Jay has 3 classics anyone that says more is d*ckeating

Kanye also has 3 IMO but he has ghostwriters
Lol d*ck eating.
+2   

 1 month ago '18        #6
Illuminati 8ob  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 23745 23 K  Slaps total: 1793 1 K
Not sure about 5 classics from Kanye but I listened to Jay way more than Ye in my life. But I’m older and not as soft as a lot of ya’ll. Ye more talented musically tho.
+31   

 1 month ago '16        #7
Head Coach 
space
space
space
Props total: 4780 4 K  Slaps total: 445 445
Id add 444 and the dynasty

 1 month ago '11        #8
dymablink  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x3
space
space
space
Props total: 8182 8 K  Slaps total: 2695 2 K
Love em both and since love for albums is subjective their classics for me personally are

Jay- Reasonable Doubt, Vol 2, BP1, BP3(aged beautifully)
Ye- Late Reg, Graduation, 808’s, MBDTF, Yeezus
-18   

Top 10 most propped recently  1 month ago '19        #9
Big Tymerz  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x10
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 24715 24 K  Slaps total: 16042 16 K
All Classics:

TCD
LR
GRADUATION
808
MBDTF
YEEZUS
PABLO
KSG
WTT



Last edited by Big Tymerz; 10-10-2019 at 12:40 AM.. Reason: Old
-22   

 1 month ago '17        #10
Imissmalcolmx17 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 7214 7 K  Slaps total: 2239 2 K
 Illuminati 8ob said
Not sure about 5 classics from Kanye but I listened to Jay way more than Ye in my life. But Im older and not as soft as a lot of yall. Ye more talented musically tho.
I dont know what world Im living in where someone would honestly listen to a Kanye fu*kin cd before Jigga. Yall take Kanye serious? Yall take those candy bars/ emotional bars seriously? Honestly what is a classic? Its very very subjective.
+13   

 1 month ago '19        #11
Johnny Drama 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2945 2 K  Slaps total: 2561 2 K
Neither of them have 3 classic albums.

Jay arguably 2
Kanye probably 1 maybe
-16   

 1 month ago '19        #12
Daddy420 
space
space
space
Props total: 542 542  Slaps total: 153 153
The thing is, if it wasnt for ye. Jay wouldnt have had the production to make classics after rd. Bc ye was on hnl vol2 and bp2 and black album. The same argument can't be made vice versa i dont think. I mean kanye is a factor im the classic jigga sound. Granted jay did make classic tracks with many different producers but for an entire project... Kanye production is behind jiggas classic run after rd


Last edited by Daddy420; 10-10-2019 at 03:28 AM..
+2   

 1 month ago '19        #13
Chaos LS 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 1047 1 K  Slaps total: 542 542
Hov has 7

Reasonable Doubt
Vol.1
Vol.2
Blueprint
Black Album
American Gangster
4:44
+1   

 1 month ago '10        #14
datguyjr 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2742 2 K  Slaps total: 591 591
Ye's 1st 6 albums are all classic imo
-8   

 1 month ago '04        #15
NahLij 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 21227 21 K  Slaps total: 1507 1 K
 Chaos LS said
Hov has 7

Reasonable Doubt
Vol.1
Vol.2
Blueprint
Black Album
American Gangster
4:44
Vol1?? Nah man. It's got some classic songs but the album as a whole? No sir
+5   

 1 month ago '04        #16
NahLij 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 21227 21 K  Slaps total: 1507 1 K
Dropout to Throne is the career of Kanye West
He retired after that and focused only on fob L fashion. That other sh*t don't count
+3   

 1 month ago '04        #17
Real 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 3307 3 K  Slaps total: 662 662
On top of that, there is no Blue Print or Black Album without Ye.
+5   

 1 month ago '18        #18
brooklynzfinest  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
space
space
Props total: 12531 12 K  Slaps total: 1965 1 K
n*ggas just throw around the word classic...sh*t is horrible.

Hov has RD, Vol 2, and the Blueprint. American gangster and TBA are strong albums but they ain't classics.

Ye has CD, Late Registration, and MBDTF...and that's it. 808s, Ye, and Yeezus are weed plates, but Graduation was a strong 4 mic album.

Watch the throne is a compilation album...i don't count those. 2 of the best should be able to carry half the album's weight. They can't individually get credit for that.

For more than 3 classics, u have to look to the goat. Illmatic, IWW, Stillmatic, Lost Tapes... And if we're being real, Untitled too (but that won't be consensus until he dies).
+7   

 1 month ago '18        #19
Therkiteckt 
space
space
space
Props total: 629 629  Slaps total: 72 72
Y'all bugging 808s isn't a classic nor is Yeezus
CD LR G MBDTF are Ye's Classics

RD Vol 2 BP BA AG 4:44 are Hov's

WTT is both

Ye didn't make the blueprint sound people credit him for it was Bink from VA and then Just Blaze n Ye kinda bit him.

CD was damn near a compilation album And all Ye sh*t has a writing team... Not sure how to compare but great music from both none the less!
+10   

 1 month ago '18        #20
Therkiteckt 
space
space
space
Props total: 629 629  Slaps total: 72 72
 brooklynzfinest said
n*ggas just throw around the word classic...sh*t is horrible.

Hov has RD, Vol 2, and the Blueprint. American gangster and TBA are strong albums but they ain't classics.

Ye has CD, Late Registration, and MBDTF...and that's it. 808s, Ye, and Yeezus are weed plates, but Graduation was a strong 4 mic album.

Watch the throne is a compilation album...i don't count those. 2 of the best should be able to carry half the album's weight. They can't individually get credit for that.

For more than 3 classics, u have to look to the goat. Illmatic, IWW, Stillmatic, Lost Tapes... And if we're being real, Untitled too (but that won't be consensus until he dies).
As usual you cant mention Jay without someone bringing Esco into it... For Nas I give him illmatic (personally I'm not a huge fan, it was dope but I get the impact) Iww, I Am and stillmatic. And if You're mentioning untitled as a classic but TBA or Graduation ain't then it's obvious where your bias is both those albums are better than untitled or the lost tapes. Nas would probably tell you that.

 1 month ago '17        #21
The Gary Group  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x10
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 35660 35 K  Slaps total: 5331 5 K
 somuchfun said
Jay has 3 classics anyone that says more is d*ckeating

Kanye also has 3 IMO but he has ghostwriters
/thread
-4   

 1 month ago '17        #22
Pythagoras 
space
space
space
Props total: 6668 6 K  Slaps total: 1573 1 K
 brooklynzfinest said
n*ggas just throw around the word classic...sh*t is horrible.

Hov has RD, Vol 2, and the Blueprint. American gangster and TBA are strong albums but they ain't classics.

Ye has CD, Late Registration, and MBDTF...and that's it. 808s, Ye, and Yeezus are weed plates, but Graduation was a strong 4 mic album.

Watch the throne is a compilation album...i don't count those. 2 of the best should be able to carry half the album's weight. They can't individually get credit for that.

For more than 3 classics, u have to look to the goat. Illmatic, IWW, Stillmatic, Lost Tapes... And if we're being real, Untitled too (but that won't be consensus until he dies).
My guy I usually agree with you but the Black Album is a no doubt classic. I think AG is a classic as well.

I agree on Kanye's classics, he has 3 classics to Jay's 5 by my count.

Agreed on Nas classics as well but would add Distant Relatives and potentially God's Son


Last edited by Pythagoras; 10-10-2019 at 07:32 AM..

 1 month ago '17        #23
Pythagoras 
space
space
space
Props total: 6668 6 K  Slaps total: 1573 1 K
 somuchfun said
Jay has 3 classics anyone that says more is d*ckeating

Kanye also has 3 IMO but he has ghostwriters
Reasonable Doubt, Vol 2, The Black Album, Blueprint, American Gangster

By my count that's 5

Kanye got CD, LR, and MBTDF

So agreed on 3 there
-2   

 1 month ago '04        #24
booie4 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2913 2 K  Slaps total: 175 175
 Johnny Drama said
Neither of them have 3 classic albums.

Jay arguably 2
Kanye probably 1 maybe
The answer is a lot closer to this than the op
+1   

 1 month ago '06        #25
jj01 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 13972 13 K  Slaps total: 5627 5 K
Yall have low standards in here.
+7   



ADVERTISEMENT
Sign me up
 
 

yesterday...


most viewed right now
online now  44
2019 Black Friday deals?
47 comments
23 hours ago
@tech
most viewed right now
+32online now  23
Article inside Welp : Marvel Studios to 'redeem' Hulk following "Endgame"
62 comments
23 hours ago
@movies
most viewed right now
+63online now  20
Jim Rome fully and correctly breaksdown what REALLY happened with Kap
192 comments
19 hours ago
@sports
most viewed right now
online now  11
PS Plus 12 Months $24.88 (Amazon)
24 comments
23 hours ago
@games
back to top
register register Follow BX @ Twitter search BX privacy