Xbox One vs. PS4 Graphics Showdown: The Rematch

most viewed right now
 142
Dec 11 - The bubble is here: People taking out mortgages to cop bitcoins
37 comments
@news
most viewed right now
 95
Whoo Kid says 50 Cent used to be out here beatin up random drug dealers
63 comments
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 71
NFL NFL Network suspends Marshall Faulk, Heath Evans, Ike Taylor due to sexual..
217 comments
@sports
most viewed right now
 69
The internet reacts to people getting finessed by the mother of the viral bull..
155 comments
@wild'ish

section   (0 bx goons and 1 bystanders) Share this on Twitter   Share this on Facebook
 

Props Slaps
 4 years ago '04        #1
7165 pageviews
65 comments


Scoop24 15 heat pts15
space
avatar space
space
$6,793 | Props total: 1366 1366
Xbox One vs. PS4 Graphics Showdown: The Rematch
 

 
Xbox One vs. PS4 Graphics Showdown: The Rematch
August 14, 2013 by YodasBoy

I wrote a post a while back comparing the graphical capabilities of the next gen systems, and (spoilers!) argued that while the PS4 had an edge on paper, it wouldn't necessarily make a significant difference in actual in-game visuals.
Now, new info has come to light, and I am no longer convinced the PS4 is the more powerful of the two consoles. On the contrary, the playing field is much more level than previously thought, and the Xbox One may even have a slight edge over Sony's machine.
Item 1: Number of CPU cores dedicated to gaming

While we've known for some time that both consoles sport the same 8-core AMD CPU, a terrible reveal was made on the Xbox front: the One only allocates 6 of these cores for gaming, with 2 cores reserved at all times for the OS. This essentially reduces the CPU power of the One to 75% of that used in the PS4, where games are concerned, right? Sure, if the PS4 utilized all 8 cores for games.


A CPU profiler showing k!llzone: Shadowfall running... wait, 6 cores?

However, it turns out that the PS4 also only allocates 6 of its 8 cores for gaming, so... nevermind then. No advantage: PS4, no advantage: Xbox One, their CPU's are identical.
Item 2: Memory allocated to the OS

The collective internets had been under the impression for some time that the One's oppressive OS configuration greedily gobbled up 3 out of the 8 GB or RAM at all times, leaving 5 GB available for running games. Good Guy Sony, meanwhile, only allocate 1 GB to the OS, leaving a whopping 7 GB for developers to utilize in their games. An extra 2 GB, gosh, that could result in faster load times, larger areas, higher res textures, more polygons on the screen, and so on. A definite advantage for the PS4.
Except for one thing. The OS in the PS4 is easily just as burdensome as (and perhaps moreso than) the one(s) sported in the Xbox. Apparently only 4.5 GB is accessible to game developers at all times, in addition to an odd configuration that allows access to an extra GB that is sort of available but not really. Based on Sony's response to this leak, that extra GB is split evenly between hard drive paging (not sure that legitimately counts, since it's not actually RAM) and another half GB that is supposedly accessible to developers (but is somehow separate, and the PS4 dev kits still run at a default 4.5 GB...). Given this, PS4 game developers have 5 GB of actual RAM to work with, tops, and most likely have closer to 4.5 GB in practice. If developers can't count on that extra GB, then they can't reliably use it, and even if they could, 5.5 GB is still quite a drop from 7 GB.


This mayhem is running on 4.5 GB, ostensibly the maximum possible on the PS4. Meanwhile, the Xbox will sport an additional half gig of RAM above that.

Instead, developers have a guaranteed 4.5 GB to play with on the PS4, and 5 GB on the One. Advantage: Xbox.
Item 3: The speed of the One's eSRAM

Commentators not caught up in the anti-Xbox mob mentality have already noted that the DDR3 RAM in the Xbox One is actually faster than the GDDR5 RAM in the PS4 under certain circumstances. There is, however another asterisk to add to the RAM speed debate.
The super-fast embedded memory of the One's GPU (of which the PS4 has no equivalent) complements the (slower) main memory in the system - this we knew all along. Microsoft later revised their numbers for this eSRAM, however, increasing the theoretical speed by 88%.
Comparing the two systems' memory as 176 GB/s (PS4) to 68 GB/s (Xbox) has never been an honest apples-to-apples comparison, since it ignores the advantages of DDR3 and the eSRAM in the One. Since that hasn't stopped anyone from making those comparisons, however, let's play that game and look at the theoretical speed of the One's memory:
192 GB/s (eSRAM) + 68 GB/s (DDR3) = 260 GB/s overall.
If we are to go off of theoretical numbers (which has been fair game for the PS4 fanboys thus far), the One destroys the PS4 with 260 GB/s vs. 176 GB/s overall RAM speed.


Booya

Item 4: Xbox's GPU boost

Another recent tidbit from Microsoft's camp is that the One's GPU has been given a clockspeed increase, albeit a minor one. The next Xbox's AMD chip now runs at 853MHz, as opposed to its original specification of 800MHz.
This isn't a big bump up, but it's a bump nonetheless. This results in roughly a 7% speed boost over the PS4's GPU and may help compensate for the One's chip sporting less GCN's.

Conclusion

All in all, we now know that the CPU's are virtually identical, the One's GPU is faster, and the RAM comparisons are much more even than previously thought. Sony's OS occupies just as many CPU cores as its Xbox counterpart, and, as it turns out, is an even greater burden on the system memory. A few months back, it looked like the PS4 had both faster and more RAM than the Xbox, but now it appears to have neither.
With these revelations, many of the PS4's supposed advantages over its competitor are essentially moot. Perhaps now the debate will shift from memory and OS burdens to some other spec comparisons, such as the number of GCN's in the graphics chips. At this point, though, the remaining differences between the two systems are trivial. If a few extra GCN's in the PS4 are all the advantage it has, then it's time for people to stop acting like the PS4 is a vastly more powerful system.
Truth is, these two systems are virtually identical, and they are a more even match than we've ever seen in past console wars. Don't count on either system having a significant edge on the hardware level. Most likely, game developers themselves will be a much bigger variable in their games' graphics than the machines they're running on.
visit this link Xbox One vs. PS4 Graphics Showdown: The Rematch - Blog by YodasBoy - IGN

65 comments for "Xbox One vs. PS4 Graphics Showdown: The Rematch"

 4 years ago '10        #2
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
A blog post by YodasBoy? Alright. I'll read it.

I hopped to the GPU and I knew someone would think the One's 853 is suddenly faster. It's not.

This is very poor writing at its finest.


Last edited by Hovi Bryant; 08-15-2013 at 11:20 AM..
 4 years ago '09        #3
29 26 6 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$11,173 | Props total: 2558 2558
Disgonbegood
 4 years ago '06        #4
ChevyBrah 216 heat pts216
space
space
space
$15,404 | Props total: 961 961
All in all, we now know that the CPU's are virtually identical, the One's GPU is faster, and the RAM comparisons are much more even than previously thought. Sony's OS occupies just as many CPU cores as its Xbox counterpart, and, as it turns out, is an even greater burden on the system memory. A few months back, it looked like the PS4 had both faster and more RAM than the Xbox, but now it appears to have neither.

:ra ydatass:
 4 years ago '06        #5
ChevyBrah 216 heat pts216
space
space
space
$15,404 | Props total: 961 961
looooooooollllllllllll uh ooooooooo
 4 years ago '05        #6
Chuck_Remixed 251 heat pts251
space
avatar space
space
$17,106 | Props total: 3554 3554
Ugh, this is a blog is just
Commentators not caught up in the anti-Xbox mob mentality have already noted that the DDR3 RAM in the Xbox One is actually faster than the GDDR5 RAM in the PS4 under certain circumstances. There is, however another asterisk to add to the RAM speed debate.

The super-fast embedded memory of the One's GPU (of which the PS4 has no equivalent) complements the (slower) main memory in the system - this we knew all along. Microsoft later revised their numbers for this eSRAM, however, increasing the theoretical speed by 88%.

Comparing the two systems' memory as 176 GB/s (PS4) to 68 GB/s (Xbox) has never been an honest apples-to-apples comparison, since it ignores the advantages of DDR3 and the eSRAM in the One. Since that hasn't stopped anyone from making those comparisons, however, let's play that game and look at the theoretical speed of the One's memory:

192 GB/s (eSRAM) + 68 GB/s (DDR3) = 260 GB/s overall.

If we are to go off of theoretical numbers (which has been fair game for the PS4 fanboys thus far), the One destroys the PS4 with 260 GB/s vs. 176 GB/s overall RAM speed.
 08-15-2013, 11:33 AM         #7
Killa Kwamz 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
 Hovi Bryant said:
A blog post by YodasBoy? Alright. I'll read it.

I hopped to the GPU and I knew someone would think the One's 853 is suddenly faster. It's not.

This is very poor writing at its finest.



Denial is the first step in recovery to a Loss.

here you go


[pic - click to view]

 4 years ago '10        #8
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
 Killa Kwamz said:



Denial is the first step in recovery to a Loss.

here you go


[pic - click to view]

You really want to do this to yourself?

Alright.

Previously, the peak GPU shader throughput for the Xbox One was 1.25 TeraFLOPS/s versus the PlayStation 4′s 1.84 TeraFLOPS/s. The Xbox One GPU boost amounts to a 6.6 percent increase in performance, so the new theoretical Xbox GPU performance is about 1.33 TeraFLOPS/s.
Read more at

You guys shouldn't try to talk about stuff you have no clue about. Just saying.
 4 years ago '12        #9
BaconGod 8 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$4,230 | Props total: 651 651
Why can't n*ggas just have a PC and buy both systems?
 4 years ago '07        #10
moe4484 4 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$8,661 | Props total: 1132 1132
If we are to go off of theoretical numbers (which has been fair game for the PS4 fanboys thus far), the One destroys the PS4 with 260 GB/s vs. 176 GB/s overall RAM speed.


 4 years ago '10        #11
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
 moe4484 said:
If we are to go off of theoretical numbers (which has been fair game for the PS4 fanboys thus far), the One destroys the PS4 with 260 GB/s vs. 176 GB/s overall RAM speed.


Y'all been on that cloud sh*t for weeks.

But GDDR5 memory is much more intuitive than ram attached to a processor.

Hey, whatever argument you guys need to sleep better at night.


 4 years ago '04        #12
Da Ill One|M 4602 heat pts4602
space
avatar space
space
$45,508 | Props total: 4990 4990
I don't give a fu*k about numbers or any of that sh*t...what the games play like is all I care about... this fanboy sh*t is rediculous...
 4 years ago '10        #13
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
 BaconGod said:
Why can't n*ggas just have a PC and buy both systems?
n*ggas can do whatever they want. However, this misinformation is k!lling a n*gga.

Kids throwing around numbers and making rash statements. My ignore list is just growing with each ignorant statement.
 08-15-2013, 11:54 AM         #14
Cya Nerd 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
Wait this hovi f*ggots done from ducking other threads he got destroyed in


 4 years ago '07        #15
moe4484 4 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$8,661 | Props total: 1132 1132
 Hovi Bryant said:
Y'all been on that cloud sh*t for weeks.

But GDDR5 memory is much more intuitive than ram attached to a processor.

Hey, whatever argument you guys need to sleep better at night.


If we are to go off of theoretical numbers (which has been fair game for the PS4 fanboys thus far), the One destroys the PS4 with 260 GB/s vs. 176 GB/s overall RAM speed.


 4 years ago '10        #16
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
 Mr I 95 said:
this is why you xbox f*ggots on this site get sh*tted on with every opportunity ...instead of being realists you cant suck enough d!cks...


ill just leave this here





what? adults that know sh*t that are xbox fans on an xbox forum speaking truth? brilliant!
Welp, this saved everyone a lot of time. The ether in there is awfully strong.
 4 years ago '06        #17
ChevyBrah 216 heat pts216
space
space
space
$15,404 | Props total: 961 961
they madddddddddddddd
 4 years ago '10        #18
Hovi Bryant 676 heat pts676
space
avatar space
space
$30,730 | Props total: 19626 19626
 Mr I 95 said:
its just disgusting how dudes try to act like a blog post on ign is some type of credible source...any one of us can go do the same thing right this second...i can go sign up for ign and make a blog saying xbox one was sold to sony right now
I know. This sh*t is pathetic. I'm just waiting for someone to co-relate this blog post with IGN's credibility or integrity at this point. Then the circle jerk would be complete.

Dumb people are predictable.
 4 years ago '07        #19
moe4484 4 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$8,661 | Props total: 1132 1132
 ChevyBrah said:
they madddddddddddddd
Furious and acting like someone from the BX typed that sh*t
 4 years ago '04        #20
Explicit 239 heat pts239
space
avatar space
space
$10,091 | Props total: 2393 2393
The fu*k people trying to base which will look better without actual gameplay from the final version of each system. Speak on this when the systems release cause right now this means sh*t.
Home      
  
 

 






most viewed right now
 70
Image(s) inside Sweet Colombian....Baddie... IDK nigga she got ass and she pretty. peep
77 comments
2 days ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 23
Article inside Kodi addon site TVAddons to stop proactively checking for piracy
25 comments
2 days ago
@tech
most viewed right now
 16
Video inside My experience after record deal (warning)
296 comments
2 days ago
@wild'ish
most viewed right now
 9
Eminem's First Week numbers for every album ranked
50 comments
1 day ago
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 8
Image(s) inside Time Traveler Came From 4127 To Get Away From Child Support
48 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 7
Elle Duncan got Cari Champion the F outta here!
89 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 7
Sakura, Blanka, Flake, Cody, G , & Sagat DLC SF5
72 comments
1 day ago
@games
most viewed right now
 6
Image(s) inside I Wanna Fu** U Hard On The Sink, After That, Give U Sumthin 2 Drink
69 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
back to top
register contact Follow BX @ Twitter Follow BX @ Facebook search BX privacy