Top ten rated QB's in NFL Madden 13

most viewed right now
 36
Video inside 50 was ready to stab up Suge back in the day
36 comments
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 34
DONT LET THESE TRAPS FOOL YOU! Here's how to effectively avoid them.
39 comments
@wild'ish
most viewed right now
 33
Image(s) inside This is what the richest zip code in America looks like
96 comments
@wild'ish
most viewed right now
 28
Video inside First she'll break your ankles, then she'll your heart!!!
21 comments
@thotsdimesetc

section   (0 bx goons and 1 bystanders) Share this on Twitter   Share this on Facebook
 

Props Slaps
 6 years ago '05        #221
b_eazy 63 heat pts63
space
avatar space
space
$18,077 | Props total: 2856 2856
 Da Ill One said:


Over the course of the next four weeks there will also be the opportunity to vote on which player, out of the designated top three, should be the highest rated in a particular category. Today the rating to opine on for QBs is “Speed” with Robert Griffin III, Michael Vick, and Terrelle Pryor in the competition to get the nod. Vote on which you think is deserving of being the fastest QB.

EA Sports today revealed the top ten overall rated quarterbacks in Madden NFL 13.


Aaron Rodgers: 99
Tom Brady: 98
Drew Brees: 98
Eli Manning: 97
Ben Roethlisberger: 95
Peyton Manning: 93
Philip Rivers: 92
Matthew Stafford: 91
Tony Romo: 90
Michael Vick: 89




In before people shred these ratings to hell...
Big Ben ahead of Stafford and Eli?









Edit: my bad, Eli should be a 95 and Stafford a 97


Last edited by b_eazy; 07-31-2012 at 05:46 PM..
 6 years ago '05        #222
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
 -BigC- said:
Isn't it kind of convient that he plays well when the defense does?

What happen in 2008 for Mr Clutch? 2009?2010? If ELIte is so great why doesn't he put up better stats? Even if you want to give him some slack for his first few years, even his last 5 aren't impressive at all Unless your count TEAM wins as something Eli does though

sh*t is crazy how great Eli is once his defense starts destroying the other teams QBs.

And no not all QBs get more credit then they deserve. I understand Peyton getting his credit because he actually puts up numbers consistently, just not that game. Brees got his because hes a monster, same with Arod. Brady didn't get credit for his first few because he was a game manager. So why does Eli?
2008 when our number 1 receiver shot himself? :lebroncmonson:

the giants defense was terrible all of 09 and most of last year and eli played great both seasons. WTF are you talking about? you clearly have something against the man for whatever reason.

 07-31-2012, 06:07 PM         #223
-BigC- 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
The only thing I have against Eli(and other similar situation QBs) is the unwarranted praise they receive. His best statistical years are what other QBs hes compared to average

He played great in 2010 with 31 TDs but 25 INTs?. His best years he has a 2:1 INT ratio at best, while again other top tier QBs only go near that in bad years. His best QB rating is 93, lower then the AVERAGES of every top tier QB.

He is a very solid QB, but his best play is no where near where you and others rank him. He wins when the defense catches fire and can't carry a team unlike the best QBs in the NFL. If you want to give him a lot of credit for the SBs when considering your rankings then fine. But he is still no where near the level of Brees/Rodgers/Brady/Peyton. I don't even think hes above Big Ben


Last edited by -BigC-; 07-31-2012 at 06:09 PM..
 6 years ago '05        #224
MlLkMan 
space
avatar space
space
$4,251 | Props total: 41 41
Rivers should be top 3
 6 years ago '05        #225
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
 -BigC- said:
The only thing I have against Eli(and other similar situation QBs) is the unwarranted praise they receive. His best statistical years are what other QBs hes compared to average

He played great in 2010 with 31 TDs but 25 INTs?. His best years he has a 2:1 INT ratio at best, while again other top tier QBs only go near that in bad years. His best QB rating is 93, lower then the AVERAGES of every top tier QB.

He is a very solid QB, but his best play is no where near where you and others rank him. He wins when the defense catches fire and can't carry a team unlike the best QBs in the NFL. If you want to give him a lot of credit for the SBs when considering your rankings then fine. But he is still no where near the level of Brees/Rodgers/Brady/Peyton. I don't even think hes above Big Ben
first of all i said he played great in 09 and last year (2011) in reference to his playing well despite the defense being THE WORST IN THE LEAGUE in 09. in 2010 the giants were signing receivers off the street because everyone got hurt left and right. combine that with several of his picks were catchable balls tipped up by receivers as well as several being late in games that we were down multiple scores and not relevant at all to grading him as a QB.

you keep mentioning stats despite the fact i've already said they don't prove anything, specifically qb rating which is an extremely flawed stat. if QB stats were the tell all romo would be considered one of the best in the game.

QB stats do not take into account the play of the Oline and players around the QB. you do realize the giants o-line was graded the worst in the NFL last season? you realize the giants running game was dead last in yards per game and yards per carry? despite that fact eli kept his team alive. did you watch the first cowboys game last year? down 12 with like 4 minutes left and the season on the line?

your comment about eli only playing well when the defense plays well couldn't be further from the truth. maybe what you're trying to say is the GIANTS only play well when the defense plays well which i wouldn't completely disagree with. the same can be said for the packers, saints and patriots. each of those teams won their superbowls when their defenses played very well in the post season.

eli has been underrated and bashed his entire career until recently. why does it bother you so much that he is finally getting praised for winning 2 superbowls? both of which he led his team on the game winning drive. how is big ben better when he's consistently had a better defense? because he holds on the ball and gets injured instead of throwing a few more picks?

i haven't seen anyone putting eli above rodgers/brees/brady so what's your problem?


Last edited by dblockallday; 07-31-2012 at 06:24 PM..
 6 years ago '11        #226
Kingpin 313 104 heat pts104
space
space
space
$19,222 | Props total: 2618 2618
 finishim said:
sorry braj, 48/6/4,600 in 15>>>>
Rodgers threw 45 TDS he wasn't getting the record





Edit: and it was 6 ints not 4
 07-31-2012, 06:33 PM         #227
-BigC- 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
Finally getting praised? Hes been overhyped since the first SB and now its just gotten out of control. He turns the ball over more then every top tier QB, throws less touchdowns then them, completes less passes then them, throws for less yards then them yet is somehow on the same level?

Other QBs have had line issues(Arod,Romo,Ben) and find ways to get it done without a ton of turnovers.

sh*ts funny that you can't see the irony in your statement of how Big Ben is better despite having a better defense. His Oline is worse and he puts up better numbers consistently then Eli.

In 9 less games he has more yards, 20 less TDs but 34 less INTs. Higher YPA, Completion %, less fumbles while having a lesser Oline and playing in a defensively tougher division

I'm done until a legitimate logical argument is provided by a Giant fan. I keep bringing up the same things and they are only ever countered with things that have no facts behind them. Give me more reasons why Eli's turns the ball over more because hes the only QB to suffer from bad tips. Or how his offense is somehow the most intricate offense in the NFL. Or how hes the reason the defense makes plays and holds high scoring offenses under 20 points consistently in the playoffs.


Last edited by -BigC-; 07-31-2012 at 06:38 PM..
 6 years ago '05        #228
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
dude mentioned romo.



dead giveaway.
 6 years ago '05        #229
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
when was the last time eli didn't poop on romo head to head? i can't even remember the last time romo beat the giants. even in 09 when our defense was atrocious we swept the cowgirls

 6 years ago '07        #230
24/7foamz 
space
avatar space
space
$14,922 | Props total: 535 535
 -BigC- said:
The Giants weren't sh*t until the defense stepped up

Eli gets about 100x more credit then he deserves for the 2 Giant superbowls. sh*t even Peyton got to much credit for his
giants was 7-7. without eli the giants wouldve been 3-11...eli won the giants 4 games alone last year when the defense was playing like a.ss watch more giant games before you talk


Last edited by 24/7foamz; 07-31-2012 at 07:11 PM..
 6 years ago '07        #231
24/7foamz 
space
avatar space
space
$14,922 | Props total: 535 535
 -BigC- said:
Finally getting praised? Hes been overhyped since the first SB and now its just gotten out of control. He turns the ball over more then every top tier QB, throws less touchdowns then them, completes less passes then them, throws for less yards then them yet is somehow on the same level?

Other QBs have had line issues(Arod,Romo,Ben) and find ways to get it done without a ton of turnovers.

sh*ts funny that you can't see the irony in your statement of how Big Ben is better despite having a better defense. His Oline is worse and he puts up better numbers consistently then Eli.

In 9 less games he has more yards, 20 less TDs but 34 less INTs. Higher YPA, Completion %, less fumbles while having a lesser Oline and playing in a defensively tougher division

I'm done until a legitimate logical argument is provided by a Giant fan. I keep bringing up the same things and they are only ever countered with things that have no facts behind them. Give me more reasons why Eli's turns the ball over more because hes the only QB to suffer from bad tips. Or how his offense is somehow the most intricate offense in the NFL. Or how hes the reason the defense makes plays and holds high scoring offenses under 20 points consistently in the playoffs.
son stop it you known to be a eli hater how the hell you gonna compare rodgers,romo and ben mobile wise?! yea they oline can suck but they can make plays with they feet something eli cant do so if eli oline sucks then he's gonna be affected by that
 6 years ago '05        #232
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
i just realized dude is a cowboys fan



i shouldn't have been wasting my time. cowboys fans prolly hate us as much as we hate philly.
 6 years ago '04        #233
Confidance 1 heat pts
space
space
space
$5,801 | Props total: 173 173
 dblockallday said:
i just realized dude is a cowboys fan



i shouldn't have been wasting my time. cowboys fans prolly hate us as much as we hate philly.
Overrated.

n*gga we beat yall with our back-up qb........ *sigh*
 07-31-2012, 07:38 PM         #234
-BigC- 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
I watch every game And I don't hate the Giants I actually like how the organization is ran. I just don't like the majority of the fans. I guess its understandable that your as delusional as Knick fans since your probably mostly fans of both teams.

If you give credit to Eli for those wins, credit him for these Ls.

The Seattle game. Where Seattle lost their starting QB. Eli throws a miracle tipped ball that Cruz takes to the house(just pointing that out to counter the argument for his tipped balls being intercepted all the time ) The 49r game(2 turnovers), Eagle game(lost to Vince Young, 3 Turnovers including basically game losing fumble in the 4th), second Redskin game(again 3 turnovers)
 6 years ago '05        #235
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
 Confidance said:
Overrated.

n*gga we beat yall with our back-up qb........ *sigh*
we always lose to backup QBs



just this past year vince young beat us, freaking charlie whitehurst beat us...




 -BigC- said:
I watch every game And I don't hate the Giants I actually like how the organization is ran. I just don't like the majority of the fans. I guess its understandable that your as delusional as Knick fans since your probably mostly fans of both teams.

If you give credit to Eli for those wins, credit him for these Ls.

The Seattle game. Where Seattle lost their starting QB. Eli throws a miracle tipped ball that Cruz takes to the house(just pointing that out to counter the argument for his tipped balls being intercepted all the time ) The 49r game(2 turnovers), Eagle game(lost to Vince Young, 3 Turnovers including basically game losing fumble in the 4th), second Redskin game(again 3 turnovers)
i thought you were done?

cruz also lost that seattle game when he tipped the ball for a pick six when we were about to score to take the lead. the tipped balls i was referencing were mainly in 2010 when he had 25 picks, like 9 of them were right off his receivers hands. another 7 or 8 were meaningless late game picks when the game was already decided. but you stat geeks will make it out like those picks lost us the games. 2010 was a failure of a season because our defense collapsed against the eagles, not because of eli's turnovers.

the 49er game both picks were on routes that manningham messed up (like always). not to mention eli dropped a perfect dime to manningham which would have tied it but it went straight through his hands.

eagles game i remember 1 bad pick in the beginning, don't remember the rest. i do remember tying it only for our defense to let vince young set a franchise record for longest drive in history. that fumble at the end was simply babin making a good play and eli, understandably not trusting his horrible o-line.

2nd redskins game i remember manningham causing a pick in the end zone too on a route he gave up on. eli threw a fade and manningham ran a fade stop SMH. also another one of the picks was a miraculous play by a safety on a deflected pass (by the defender covering, not the receiver)

our defense allowed 2 3rd and 15+ conversions in that game if i remember correctly. SMH i do blame the offense mainly for that loss though.


Last edited by dblockallday; 07-31-2012 at 07:52 PM..
 6 years ago '07        #236
24/7foamz 
space
avatar space
space
$14,922 | Props total: 535 535
 -BigC- said:
I watch every game And I don't hate the Giants I actually like how the organization is ran. I just don't like the majority of the fans. I guess its understandable that your as delusional as Knick fans since your probably mostly fans of both teams.

If you give credit to Eli for those wins, credit him for these Ls.

The Seattle game. Where Seattle lost their starting QB. Eli throws a miracle tipped ball that Cruz takes to the house(just pointing that out to counter the argument for his tipped balls being intercepted all the time ) The 49r game(2 turnovers), Eagle game(lost to Vince Young, 3 Turnovers including basically game losing fumble in the 4th), second Redskin game(again 3 turnovers)
sea game you forgot eli drove them down the field had them about to score when cruz slipped on his route and tip the ball off which got picked returned for a touchdown which ended the game but you dont mention that and it was the defense who let a backup move the ball up and down the game.

the niners game one of the inteception was manningham stopping on his route and eli throwing the ball where he expected him to be.the other interception was running the same play back to back leading to an interception thats just defense awareness on the niners defense.

the eagles game i can only speak on the fumble because thats the only turnover i recall eli stepped up in the pocket from babin and babin hustling sacked/strip the ball from eli when the giants was moving the ball it was another good play from a de not giving up on a play how about you just give that de props on hustling and knocking eli on every turnover
 6 years ago '11        #237
KING JAYY 541 heat pts541
space
avatar space
space
$53,486 | Props total: 23125 23125
Why the fu*k is Rodgers ranked higher than Brady
 6 years ago '07        #238
24/7foamz 
space
avatar space
space
$14,922 | Props total: 535 535
 dblockallday said:
we always lose to backup QBs



just this past year vince young beat us, freaking charlie whitehurst beat us...





i thought you were done?

cruz also lost that seattle game when he tipped the ball for a pick six when we were about to score to take the lead. the tipped balls i was referencing were mainly in 2010 when he had 25 picks, like 9 of them were right off his receivers hands. another 7 or 8 were meaningless late game picks when the game was already decided. but you stat geeks will make it out like those picks lost us the games. 2010 was a failure of a season because our defense collapsed against the eagles, not because of eli's turnovers.

the 49er game both picks were on routes that manningham messed up (like always). not to mention eli dropped a perfect dime to manningham which would have tied it but it went straight through his hands.

eagles game i remember 1 bad pick in the beginning, don't remember the rest. i do remember tying it only for our defense to let vince young set a franchise record for longest drive in history. that fumble at the end was simply babin making a good play and eli, understandably not trusting his horrible o-line.

2nd redskins game i remember manningham causing a pick in the end zone too on a route he gave up on. eli threw a fade and manningham ran a fade stop SMH. also another one of the picks was a miraculous play by a safety on a deflected pass (by the defender covering, not the receiver)

our defense allowed 2 3rd and 15+ conversions in that game if i remember correctly. SMH i do blame the offense mainly for that loss though.
damn props we type the same sh*t at the sametime
 6 years ago '05        #239
dblockallday 
space
avatar space
space
$8,918 | Props total: 1674 1674
o i forgot manningham only messed up on that one pick in the niners game... the other one was when we ran back to back plays like you said. i remember eli dropped a perfect pass to cruz on a post route who was wide open and he dropped it. we came back with the same play for some reason and this time rodgers jumped in front and snatched it. good play by a good cb.

cruz abused him both games tho. dude prolly had nightmares about trying to cover that boy on the option route. i remember in sound fx on nfl network rodgers was like "i can't cover no damn option route all day, everytime i go in he breaks out, everytime i go out he breaks in"



Last edited by dblockallday; 07-31-2012 at 08:01 PM..
 07-31-2012, 08:01 PM         #240
-BigC- 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
Conclussion: Eli has never thrown an interception that was his fault. Yet if anyone ever mentions reasoning for other QBs interceptions its excuses.

@ NY fans
Home      
  
 

 






most viewed right now
 17
Image(s) inside This girl is so fcking ugly Oh my but her body A1
129 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 14
May 21 - Dad takes late son's girlfriend to prom, one month after fatal crash
58 comments
1 day ago
@news
most viewed right now
 9
Image(s) inside Damn! Tina Fey Is Getting Thick
74 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 7
Motion Capture King Andy Serkis Takes On Jungle Book In First Trailer For ‘Mow..
33 comments
1 day ago
@movies
most viewed right now
 5
Video inside Jose Guapo out here down bad
61 comments
1 day ago
@misc
most viewed right now
 4
Image(s) inside H1z1 drops on PS4 tomorrow, here’s 11 tips to dominate
58 comments
1 day ago
@games
most viewed right now
 4
Video inside k dot kicks w**** girl off stage for n****
614 comments
1 day ago
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 4
Image(s) inside TAYLOR BANNER out here looking like something to eat! 🌱
91 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
back to top
register contact Follow BX @ Twitter Follow BX @ Facebook search BX privacy