We need to settle this once and for all... Troy Polamalu vs. Ed Reed. Who's better?

most viewed right now
 199
Image(s) inside #DC4 on the way? (shots at Drake and OVO)
88 comments
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 152
Image(s) inside 50 Cent Is In Serious Trouble For making Fun of a Mentally Handicapped..
291 comments
@hiphop
most viewed right now
 133
NBA Prince's favorite player wasn't MJ, Lebron, Kobe, magic...it was....
30 comments
@sports
most viewed right now
 130
NBA Atlanta Hawks (4) vs. Cleveland Cavs (1) Eastern Conference Semifinals
401 comments
@sports

section   (0 bx goons and 1 bystanders) Share this on Twitter   Share this on Facebook
 

Who's better?
Troy Polamalu 83 22.49%
Ed Reed 286 77.51%
Voters: 369. Sorry, you cannot vote on this poll (Boxden members only)

[Click here to become a member]

Props Slaps
 4 years ago '11        #1
10378 pageviews
194 comments


Yinz N Burgh 102 heat pts102
space
avatar space
space
$14,800 | Props total: 366 366
We need to settle this once and for all... Troy Polamalu vs. Ed Reed. Who's better?
 

 
READ THE THREAD AND LOOK AT THE STATS BEFORE YOU FORM YOUR OPINION


DON'T FORGET REED HAS A SEASON ON POLAMALU



Troy - 123 games played. 607 tackles. 458 solo. 149 a.ssist. 9 sacks. 29 interceptions.

Ed - 144 games played. 548 tackles. 456 solo. 92 a.ssist. 6 sacks. 57 interceptions.


ACCOMPLISHMENTS

Reed - DPOY in 2004. 0 Super Bowl Appearances.

Polamalu - DPOY in 2010. 3 Super Bowl Appearances.

And not 1...


[pic - click to view]



But 2....


[pic - click to view]






[pic - click to view]


top in section
 22
98 comments
top in sports
top in section
 51
12 comments
top in games
top in section
 21
5 comments
top in news

 

 
 
 
 4 years ago '07        #2
infrared AJ6 11 heat pts11
space
avatar space
space
$2,060 | Props total: 343 343
troy polamalu is a fkin beast. have you seen his numbers? offenses avoid this dude like the plague. his 2 superbowl wins cannot be denied.

my vote goes to ed reed, though.
 
 4 years ago '07        #3
Pistol Peter 33 heat pts33
space
avatar space
space
$26,690 | Props total: 3 3
depends on what you like in a safety...i like a ball hawk and ed would be nasty in lovie smiths defense...so i'm going with ed...but i do think troy has a better all around game

you really can't go wrong with neither
 
 4 years ago '08        #4
Soda Pop 5 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$7,565 | Props total: 187 187
I hate, hate, hate the Ravens but I gotta o wit Ed he constantly produces even with injuries.
 
 4 years ago '04        #5
killadre 195 heat pts195
space
avatar space
space
$14,648 | Props total: 936 936
Ed Reed gets his team turnovers w/ a short field. so Ed imo and also the players of the NFL

Troy had the luxury playing w/ more high powered offenses to help get those rings. Not to mention the *XL WIN


Last edited by killadre; 06-21-2012 at 02:15 PM..
 
 4 years ago '08        #6
Eagles All Day 61 heat pts61
space
avatar space
space
$26,050 | Props total: 779 779
Ed Reed no doubt about it
 
 4 years ago '10        #7
smoothSeph 55 heat pts55
space
avatar space
space
$6,043 | Props total: 121 121
 
 06-21-2012, 02:19 PM         #8
Cowboys All Day 
space
space
space
$n/a | Props total:  
12-1
 
 4 years ago '09        #9
WasabiTuna 16 heat pts16
space
avatar space
space
$4,983 | Props total: 377 377
Ed reed. For all the good Troy does there are a bunch of times where he overcommits and is caught out of position. You could make a case where he was to blame for that Super Bowl lose.
 
 4 years ago '10        #10
SeattleLost 768 heat pts768
space
avatar space
space
$60,169 | Props total: 1400 1400
Mr. Ed Reed
 
 4 years ago '11        #11
Ralph Nautica 52 heat pts52
space
avatar space
space
$9,031 | Props total: 855 855
Ed motherfu*kin' Reed n*gga
 
 4 years ago '09        #12
ReggieA 196 heat pts196
space
avatar space
space
$38,866 | Props total: 198 198
Ima go with Reed, much respect for Troy, but Reed is just constantly making more plays. I mean dude was top 10 in the league in picks only playing a half season. Sucks he may never win one, but I thinl respectively, him and TP43 are 1a and 1b, but I want Ed Reed on my team before Troy.
 
 4 years ago '07        #13
Mr.NYCinNC 22 heat pts22
space
avatar space
space
$9,473 | Props total: 0 0
Ed Reed>


[video - click to view]


 
 4 years ago '05        #14
dahabi 87 heat pts87
space
avatar space
space
$10,402 | Props total: 140 140
Troy is much better in the run game tho, people are sleeping on that. He's the one safety in the league that is actually a game changer in that aspect.
 
 4 years ago '11        #15
Ralph Nautica 52 heat pts52
space
avatar space
space
$9,031 | Props total: 855 855

[video - click to view]


miss the first six games of the season? Oh arrd, let me just come back and lead the league with 8 picks.

 
 4 years ago '08        #16
GhostNinja 47 heat pts47
space
avatar space
space
$3,944 | Props total: 0 0
i'd take ed reed over troy but it close not 16 - 1
 
 4 years ago '11        #17
Kingpin 313 94 heat pts94
space
avatar space
space
$17,764 | Props total: 107 107
They both do different things one plays the run the other plays the pass





I can't decide
 
 4 years ago '11        #18
DRAGONFLY JONES 129 heat pts129
space
avatar space
space
$8,218 | Props total: 56 56


2x more ints
4x more tds

Ed Reed>>
 
 4 years ago '09        #19
A2P89 2 heat pts
space
avatar space
space
$2,445 | Props total: 6 6
Thread backfired. it's all good Yinz, I feel you. U a steeler faithful and think Troy don't get the respect he deserves.

1a 1b can't miss with either.
 
 4 years ago '05        #20
Saintaholic 86 heat pts86
space
avatar space
space
$20,319 | Props total: 17 17
Ed easily.....he converts his picks into points and he's not a liability in coverage. SBs are a team accomplishment so remove that from the argument.
 
Home      
  
 

 






most viewed right now
 46
Image(s) inside Would you Bury your dick in her as-hole? Cosplay/Gamer chick
132 comments
23 hours ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 34
Image(s) inside That flexability :leodatass:
73 comments
1 day ago
@thotsdimesetc
most viewed right now
 31
Image(s) inside BX Detectives : Lex Luthor's painting
24 comments
1 day ago
@movies
most viewed right now
 27
Black Ink chicks got Stiff Neck...is it Tats effect?
103 comments
23 hours ago
@movies
most viewed right now
 26
Image(s) inside Kicks you thought were hot, but years later realized they were crap an..
223 comments
23 hours ago
@gear
most viewed right now
 14
Image(s) inside Apr 29 - The Smart Reason This Billionaire Wears All Black Everyday
147 comments
2 days ago
@news
most viewed right now
 14
Image(s) inside Post Your Pickups May 2016
31 comments
23 hours ago
@gear
most viewed right now
 7
NFL Crazy, money grubbing ex wife of HOH Sanders wants to go to court for free
56 comments
22 hours ago
@sports
back to top
register contact Follow BX @ Twitter Follow BX @ Facebook search BX privacy