As of now McNabb is still on that same team with "millions of holes" he threw more Ints than TDs last year. and let's be real it's the system that andy reid ran that made mcnabb seem as valuable as he was. Vick played in 12 games and had over 3000 yds passing, he never did that in his career and only threw over 2500 yds once with the falcons.
I don't wanna drag this on too long because we'll probably never agree...but I watched the games last year, and watched the games before then. I like to add perspective to numbers. The Redskins struggled in pretty much every area statistically possible....defensively....rushing...lack of quality players...everything. That's a fact...
You say Reid made McNabb seem valuable which in the end says all you think about McNabb. You can equally argue that McNabb AND Vick are making Reid look better than he actually is. It's hard to argue Reid was making McNabb look good when his offense is 80% pass, 20% run. The same things that McNabb did that made Reid look good are the same things Vick's doing now....improvising...avoiding sacks...and making up for Andy Reid's ridiculous play calling and refusal to add balance to his offense despite having really good RBs.
In fact if you really wanna break it down...you'll realize that it's Vicks scrambling and 5 yard running Tds that helped make the offense explosive...NOT Andy Reid. And it was the same with McNabb before
Rex Grossman came in and did better than Mcnabb /thread
Sure. You can say that if you have short term memory and only pick at certain facts