Name something critical about AG. What did it do to his career? What place does it hold in hip-hop? Black album was the last time we will get jay z in top form. Just like eminem show was the last his fans will get from eminem in top form. But yea, AG did have blue magic was a 10/10 song. As an album tho, nah. BP2 trumps.
How the fu*k is Pray, No Hook, Roc Boys, Sweet, Ignorant sh*t, Blue Magic, American Gangster, American Dreamin, and Fallin NOT Jay in top form? Lyrically, that album is DEFINITELY Jay on his A game. Go look at the reviews, that album was very well received.