If you are grading a body of work you can't undermine what Brady, Manning, Brees has done the last few years.
I will say he's top 5 right behind them.... but is another solid season away from overtaking Brees and maybe one more ring to be ahead or alongside Manning.
this isn't directed at you, just using part of your post
when did you guys start rating brees so high?
he has two seasons with a qb rating over 100, as does Rodgers, he has a ring as does Rodgers, even with his couple great years his lifetime qb rating is still at 91, yes it can be an overrating stat, but, Rodgers already has better playoff stats, and as many playoff wins in two less games
I guess you guys could just be giving the vet the edge, which I can respect, IMO it just seems Rodgers is going to keep progressing while brees will just keep getting older
and yes Rodgers doesn't have the legacy of manning or Brady yet, but it would seem brees and Rodgers are on their level skill wise