4,341
 

HEREDITARY & MIDSOMMAR are just remakes of older, worse horror movies


ADVERTISEMENT
 


section  x1   |  0 bx goons and 1 bystanders Share this on Twitter       Share this on Facebook

section tv / movies
  
 5 days ago '06        #1
899 page views
28 comments


SM  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 137697 137 K  Slaps total: 28267 28 K
HEREDITARY & MIDSOMMAR are just remakes of older, worse horror movies
 

 

Ari Aster has been praised for his brand of “arthouse horror,” delivering thoroughly unsettling films while simultaneously exploring mature emotional themes. His films are visually arresting, to be sure, and the standout shocks of his breakout hit Hereditary are the kind that stick with you for years, waiting to pop back up in your mind’s eye every time you turn out the lights. But while Aster is unquestionably a skilled director, his stories are extremely basic plots that rely on tried-and-true scary movie tropes. In fact, both Hereditary and his follow-up Midsommar are essentially remakes of bad horror movies. Two very specific ones, in fact.

But first, let me speak on this “arthouse horror” nonsense, because I very much object to it. It has stuck in my craw like a telephone pole traveling at 40 mph.

Aster has repeatedly referred to his breakout hit Hereditary as “a family tragedy,” acknowledging the horror elements while minimizing their importance to the story. Hereditary, if you’ll recall, is the movie that features a young girl’s severed head getting devoured by ants on a rural highway, several nekkid men leering at a teenage boy in the shadows of a creepy house, a grief-stricken mother feverishly decapitating herself with piano wire, and a headless body levitating into a treehouse to complete a demonic ritual. We get glimpses of an estranged family collapsing in the wake of a tragedy, sure, but when the plot summary of your movie is “a demon murders three people so that a cult of his followers can deposit his spirit into a teenage boy,” you’ve made a horror movie. The tragedy is incidental. That’s like Richard Donner calling The Omen “a political thriller.”

Hereditary is about a grief-stricken family falling prey to evil forces, but it is not a film about grief. It doesn’t explore the emotion or its consequences in a realistic manner. Aster insists horror was the tool he used to tell his tragedy, when in actuality the opposite is true. The tragedy is in service to the horror, not vice versa. In contrast, The Babadook and Lake Mungo are examples of horror being used as a lens through which to tell a story about the effect grief and loss actually has on a family.

With his follow-up Midsommar, Aster has said his intent was to make a breakup film couched in folk horror. But Midsommar is mostly a failure as a horror movie. It’s two-and-a-half hours of bizarre comedy lumbering towards a conclusion so obvious Aster literally shows it to the audience in the very first frame as if to say “fu*k it, you all know where this is going.” To his credit, Aster has acknowledged that Midsommar’s finale is predictable, and that his goal was to surprise the audience with the journey of his main character Dani (Florence Pugh) and the ultimate choice she makes. (Although, I would argue that Dani’s fate is also pretty telegraphed, considering I was expecting an additional reveal that kindly cult thirst trap Pelle had somehow murdered her parents and sister to push her into the arms of the Hårga.)

Interestingly, Aster wrote Midsommar for-hire, after a studio pitched him their idea for a folk horror film in the style of Eli Roth’s Hostel. Roth and Aster couldn’t be further apart in terms of critical praise. But Aster’s lofty self-evaluation of Midsommar as a breakup film told against a backdrop of otherist horror could also be applied to Roth’s thunderous flop The Green Inferno, which is similarly about a college student trying to gain the attention of an emotionally distant, manipulative a**hole before ultimately finding salvation thanks to a group of supposed savages.

Virtually every classic horror movie begins from a place of recognizable characters experiencing relatable emotions, and then plays off of the fears a*sociated with that emotion as things spiral out of control. For instance, The Exorcist is about a struggling single mother. Rosemary’s Baby is about an abusive marriage. Candyman is about racism and poverty. Wes Craven’s Shocker is about the dangers of the death penalty giving dangerous felons electricity powers. I appreciate that Aster understands that movies need to be about something relatable to truly resonate with an audience, but he’s not reinventing the wheel here. It’s like when Ryan Murphy thought he’d created the first horror comedy when he unveiled Scream Queens.

But I digress. The most damning piece of “Ari Aster’s films are actually super basic” evidence is that they’re both thinly-veiled remakes of older, worse horror movies. Hereditary is like a blown-out arthouse version of Paranormal Activity, and Midsommar is so close to The Wicker Man that I thought I’d missed “based on The Wicker Man” in the opening credits. Hear me out.

Hereditary is essentially the story of the first four Paranormal Activity films condensed into a single two-hour film. (Which is what you would get if you cut out all the time those movies devote to watching characters sleep while absolutely nothing happens.) If you haven’t seen any of the Paranormal flicks, here’s a quick rundown: A coven of witches commune with a demon named “Toby” and try to find him a human vessel. Toby works his way through several female hosts before getting to the male child he actually wants. Kind of sounds exactly like the demon in Hereditary, right?

Sisters Katie and Kristi first get exposed to Toby when they are little girls. Their grandmother Lois is the leader of the coven, and she uses Toby to k*ll the girls’ mother and gain custody of the girls. Later, as adults, Kristi and Katie both become possessed by Toby, with Katie ultimately k*lling her boyfriend Micah, Kristi, and Kristi’s husband Daniel, and kidnapping Kristi’s infant son Hunter. It’s hinted that Lois made some kind of bargain with Tobi and Hunter was the price of the bargain, so Hunter is the vessel Tobi has wanted all along. Toby’s single-minded pursuit to possess Hunter is the focus of the fourth film as well, although by that point things get pretty confusing (Hunter somehow gets adopted by another family and is living under a different name, despite getting thoroughly abducted by his demon-infested aunt the last time we saw him).

The plot of Hereditary is almost identical, albeit with a few less characters involved. Annie’s mother Ellen is involved in a coven dedicated to resurrecting a demon, exactly like Kristi and Katie’s grandmother Lois in the Paranormal movies. Ellen puts the Hell King Paimon’s spirit into Annie’s daughter Charlie, because she wasn’t allowed anywhere near Annie’s son Peter when he was little thanks to their strained relationship. Charlie is merely a placeholder – Paimon needs to inhabit a male body, and Peter was always the intended vessel. Paimon causes Charlie’s death, then possesses Annie, who burns her husband Steve alive somehow in a scene that still doesn’t make any damn sense before sawing her own head off with a wire. With the family out of the way, the coven is finally able to complete the ritual of injecting Peter with that sweet sweet demon, and all hail King Paimon.

So, both Hereditary and Paranormal Activity begin with a demon-worshipping matriarch who summons a Lord of Hell to infest her grandchildren. And in both movies, the demon gets put into the wrong female host, and then k*lls his way through the entire family to get to the magic special boy he always wanted.

Midsommar is straight-up The Wicker Man. It’s not even subtle. In Midsommar, college student Dani has an emotional breakdown after her sister k*lls herself and both of their parents in a murder-suicide. Several months later, Dani goes to Sweden with her boyfriend, his idiot pals, and an exchange student named Pelle, who has invited them to the peculiar secluded village where he grew up to celebrate Midsommar. It’s a pretty typical harvest celebration, with a maypole and a May Queen and all that, except for the fact that the celebration only occurs once every 90 years. Also, it takes place during the time of year in which the sun never fully sets, casting everything in permanent daylight. One by one, Dani’s friends are k*lled by the cult, until we ultimately learn that they were all intended to be harvest sacrifices. Dani escapes this fate because she’s been chosen as the May Queen, and as such she gets to decide the final sacrifice. So she picks her lame boyfriend Christian, who is stuffed into a bear suit and burned alive inside a giant barn, alongside several corpses and a few other volunteers from the community.

In The Wicker Man, police detective Neil Howie travels to a pagan community on the island of Summerisle to search for a missing girl named Rowan. The cultists are in the middle of celebrating May Day, and they’ve elected a young girl as May Queen each year to lead the festivities. The cultists all tell Howie that they’ve never heard of Rowan, but he finds her name in a school registry and begins to suspect that she’s been elected the May Queen, and will subsequently be sacrificed in some kind of ritual. He steals a costume to infiltrate the May Day parade and rescue Rowan, only to discover that she was merely bait and that he was always meant to be the sacrifice. They toss him into a giant Wicker Man and burn him alive to appease their gods and ensure a good harvest in the following year. In the infamous Nicolas Cage version, Cage infiltrates the May Day parade while dressed in a bear costume.

Midsommar/Summerisle, the May Day harvest celebration, maypole dancing, the pivotal election of a May Queen, and the notion of tricking outsiders to come to the village of their own free will to then be burned as sacrifices are all obvious connections, as well as the final sacrifice being a dude hilariously stuffed inside a bear suit. In both Midsommar and The Wicker Man, the cultists surround the final burning effigy to sing / mimic the agonized wails of the dying. Both movies also take place almost exclusively during the day, which is rare for horror films.

The Wicker Man is based on a book called Ritual by David Pinner, and Midsommar is close enough to both that Pinner could probably sue. At the very least, it’s Wicker Man fanfiction. Interestingly, Pinner has stated that he’d sold the rights to his novel to Christopher Lee in 1971, two years before The Wicker Man came out. (Lee appears in the film as Lord Summerisle, the leader of the community.) Even though that film heavily borrows from his novel, Pinner didn’t receive a credit until the 2006 Wicker Man remake. He must be used to his story getting ripped off by now.

Anyway, I don’t hate Ari Aster’s films. Ok, that’s not true, I hated Midsommar, kind of. I definitely can’t wait for him to make a 187 minute film about a kid befriending a doll that becomes possessed by the soul of a serial k*ller and murders his whole family. Aster will call it “a film about divorce spun through the spindle of horror” and nobody will question it. Hail King Paimon!
-10   



best
worst
28 comments
 

 4 days ago '04        #2
skillahmang 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 26763 26 K  Slaps total: 6322 6 K
Yeah somebodys mad there movie aint poppin
+3   

 4 days ago '18        #3
danneywilliams  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x2
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9512 9 K  Slaps total: 10508 10 K
Whoever wrote this garbage is a straight up hater. Midsommar was a masterpiece. Dude's basic argument is "there is nothing new under the sun" and what I say to that is "no sh*t." Ari Aster did an incredible job with Midsommar. Best film of 2019 and yes that includes Joker. Didn't really like Hereditary, though.
+4   

 4 days ago '06        #4
SM  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1 OP
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 137697 137 K  Slaps total: 28267 28 K
What's your take @ ?
-1   

 4 days ago '14        #5
Sir Tits McGee 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2508 2 K  Slaps total: 183 183
Haven't seen midsommar, wasn't a fan of hereditary and I had people hyping that sh*t up left and right
+3   

 4 days ago '12        #6
Pleasure Boy  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 12670 12 K  Slaps total: 1759 1 K
Midsommar is one of the most irritating movies I've ever watched... Stupid fu*king movie so much sh*t happen in the movie which they dont explain... And the sh*t is just dragged out for absolutely no reason... Stupid fu*king movie
-1   

 4 days ago '17        #7
lucifershammer 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 34423 34 K  Slaps total: 3601 3 K
Nothing is new
+1   

 4 days ago '04        #8
JFamis 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 7973 7 K  Slaps total: 1120 1 K
 SM said
What's your take @ ?
This article is terrible and you had to be mad thirsty for a hot topic to share it
+2   

 4 days ago '18        #9
MaFF 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 627 627  Slaps total: 138 138
Loved both movies. fu*k reading all that hater sh*t
+5   

 4 days ago '06        #10
Storchaveli  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 9528 9 K  Slaps total: 2489 2 K
 MaFF said
Loved both movies. fu*k reading all that hater sh*t
This. Also, I’m not exactly sure WHY.... but I’d tongue Florence Pugh’s a*s.

/thread
+6   

 4 days ago '17        #11
justin747  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 89568 89 K  Slaps total: 9514 9 K
I thought Heredity was HORRIBLE

-1   

 4 days ago '06        #12
Kingme 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 14531 14 K  Slaps total: 2770 2 K
I agree that Midsommar was a Wicker Man remake but I haven't seen Paranormal Activity since it came out to be able to say he copied Hereditary but I don't doubt it.

Ari Aster movies give me that close but no cigar feeling every time. I'm not in a hurry to revisit Midsommar or Hereditary anytime soon.
+2   

 4 days ago '19        #13
BOLO1  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2227 2 K  Slaps total: 449 449
Demōnic troglōdyte works of overrated "art"
+1   

 4 days ago '07        #14
MOTTAFOOKAH 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 2218 2 K  Slaps total: 375 375
Both Hereditary and Midsommar were fire... havent got to check out Lighthouse yet, but that looked good as well
+2   

 4 days ago '04        #15
ILLUSHUN 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 686 686  Slaps total: 53 53
Hereditary was genuinely scary and original. Midsommar on the other hand? Misleading and terrible lol.
+3   

 4 days ago '04        #16
Skilllz 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 10695 10 K  Slaps total: 1130 1 K
Those who can't.. critique

FOH

Both of them sh*ts was great flicks, albeit "Hereditary" was a tad bit better in a traditional way. "Midsommar" was beautifully shot.

can't stand critics, mane. Never read reviews on sh*t, I base my own opinion. Them n*ggaz sound bitter af


Last edited by Skilllz; 12-02-2019 at 08:14 PM..
+5   

 4 days ago '06        #17
Badnewz100  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 21595 21 K  Slaps total: 563 563
MidSommar was a beautifully shot movie the visuals were dope. That is all I liked about that movie. Remember being hyped for it and leaving think the movie was a 2 hour and some change mushroom trip.
+2   

 4 days ago '06        #18
SM  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x1 OP
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 137697 137 K  Slaps total: 28267 28 K
 Badnewz100 said
MidSommar was a beautifully shot movie the visuals were dope. That is all I liked about that movie. Remember being hyped for it and leaving think the movie was a 2 hour and some change mushroom trip.
Yup both looked great but are not good movies
+1   

 4 days ago '17        #19
QdobaCasanova 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 34665 34 K  Slaps total: 8080 8 K
Zoomer makes dumb parallel for no discernible reason.

Also suggets Wicker Man is a bad movie.


Midsommar can be viewed as Wicker Man in the most broadest sense imaginable and the parallel between Paranormal Activity and Hereditary makes me think this person hasn’t watched either of the things theyre bi*ching about.


Also if youre gonna sh*t on Ari, bring up how Midsommar and Hereditary follow the same plot progression and even borrow the same filming techniques to convey the same things.

Like criticize the fact that he seemingly has no idea how to make his films meet a conclusive ending without having a large exposition dump in the last 15 minutes so that the film doesn’t end with a big question mark.

And this is coming from a guy that thinks Hereditary is one of the best horror films of the past 5 years.

The article’s just stupid.


Last edited by QdobaCasanova; 12-02-2019 at 11:20 PM..
+1   

Top 10 most propped recently  4 days ago '14        #20
Doc Logical  topics gone triple plat - Number 1 spot x9
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 83170 83 K  Slaps total: 24601 24 K
I was checking this, flying through and then said

NOPE.

The minute I read...Hereditary is like a arthouse Paranormal activity.


Oooooooooh boy, the future is gonna suck.
+1   

 3 days ago '09        #21
WezLFaCe_KiD 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 1663 1 K  Slaps total: 1219 1 K
 ILLUSHUN said
Hereditary was genuinely scary and original. Midsommar on the other hand? Misleading and terrible lol.
100% agree
+1   

 3 days ago '16        #22
007imayeseekay 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 5185 5 K  Slaps total: 770 770
They were basic White scary movies...like Annabelle & The Conjuring.

They were ok, but not scary.

 3 days ago '05        #23
Emperor85 
space
space
space
Props total: 10687 10 K  Slaps total: 2762 2 K


 3 days ago '10        #24
MrTripleDouble 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 5525 5 K  Slaps total: 2119 2 K
He's hackneyed but does in a unique and beautiful way, a craftsman more than an artist. Midsummer was a beautiful film. I love the costumes, set design, cinematography and direction, good script and acting, good score. A work of art if I'm honest. Hereditary was OK, I visit it every once in a while. It's heavier and more cerebral than Midsommar, not as direct, kind of cryptic. May take a few viewings to appreciate it, Midsommar I got right away and enjoyed right away.

 3 days ago '12        #25
BrokenSafety 
space
avatar space
space
Props total: 4091 4 K  Slaps total: 514 514
Dude writing this is an idiot. Hereditary is nothing like paranormal activity. If anything the ending was straight from rosemarys bsby



ADVERTISEMENT
Sign me up
 
 

yesterday...


most viewed right now
online now  35
Image(s) inside Chevy Corvette SUV on its way?
30 comments
23 hours ago
@rides
most viewed right now
+121online now  25
Rappers who turned out a whole lot differently than they started
133 comments
1 day ago
@hiphop
most viewed right now
+31online now  15
Spotify Wrapped 2019 just dropped... what is your top artist and top song?
188 comments
1 day ago
@hiphop
most viewed right now
+82online now  12
Video inside 8 years ago we lost a comedy goat
62 comments
2 days ago
@movies
back to top
register register Follow BX @ Twitter search BX privacy